Shirebrook principal is invited to Ofsted after calling for it to be scrapped

A Shirebrook school principal who publicly called for the education watchdog Ofsted to be scrapped has been invited to a meeting - to help it decide how to change for the better.

Mark Cottingham, principal of Shirebrook Academy, described the organisation’s set up as “deeply flawed” in his regular column in the Mansfield Chad earlier this month.

Claiming that it has “no discernible impact on standards whatsoever”, Mr Cottingham said that its reports dated quickly and that a bad Ofsted report could be devastating to a school’s reputation.

In summary, he said, Ofsted should be scrapped and replaced with a new system using local inspectors, with only the most under-performing schools referred to the Government.

Shirebrook Academy head Mark Cottingham. Penguin PR: public realtions, media and communications

Just days after the column was published on the Chad’s website, Mr Cottingham received a phone call from Ofsted inviting him in for a meeting with Emma Ing, regional director of Ofsted for the East Midlands, who had read what he had to say.

During the meeting, which was also attended by Steve McMullan, the Senior HMI for Derbyshire, Mr Cottingham was asked to discuss his thoughts and suggest ways in which Ofsted, rather than scrapping itself, could improve to help teachers, students and parents get more out of the system.

He now says that that he is feeling more confident about Ofsted’s ability to properly rate schools after learning in detail how it wants to switch away from judging schools based on their exam results and looking at their all-round benefits to students, including teaching them subjects such as art, PE and Music and arranging extra-curricular activities.

Mr Cottingham said: “While I knew that Ofsted weren’t calling to arrange an inspection, I was apprehensive about what they would say to me, bearing in mind I had called for the organisation to be scrapped.

“As it turned out, the meeting was very positive. They admitted that Ofsted has become too focussed on exam results and that it wants to change its judgement criteria in order to take more of what a school was doing for its students into account.

Ofsted is launching a consultation to find out what teachers want and I was pleased to have been able to share my point of view.

Ofsted still wants to give schools ratings, which I don’t agree with, but I’m happier knowing that parents will be given a fuller picture about a school’s strengths, which will help them to decide which school is best for their child in the future.”

Last month Ofsted announced that it plans to launch its consultation in January to ask teaching professionals about its proposal to replace the section based on pupil outcomes – which looked at exam results – with a new judgement for quality of education.

It eventually hopes to introduce the new inspection criteria in September next year.


Shirebrook Academy is based in Common Lane, Shirebrook. It has 840 students and was rated “outstanding” by Ofsted in 2013, with staff and pupils alike praised by inspectors, who also singled out the considerable care the school gives to individual students as one of the Academy’s particular strengths.

In May 2017 Shirebrook Academy joined Aston Community Education Trust (ACET), benefitting from the efficiencies to be gained from high quality centralised services and the challenge and support of ACET’s School Improvement Team.

For more details contact Simon Burch at Penguin PR by ringing 01332 347779 or emailing

Penguin PR is a Public Relations Agency serving Nottingham, Derby and the East Midlands. Run by award winning journalists we'll get headlines in newspapers, on Social media, online and radio and TV news